When sociologist Yoneji Masuda coined the term information society nearly 50 years ago, no one could have imagined the power technology would come to wield, as demonstrated by the ubiquity of artificial intelligence. Today, AI writes emails, summarizes and translates texts, recommends bands, and plans itineraries. But it's also making its way into every field of knowledge, including an area that once seemed beyond its reach: creativity, long considered a uniquely human ability. Then again, the arrival of AI in artists’ studios isn’t all that surprising when you consider that the history of art is, in many ways, a history of its tools. The paintbrush, the camera obscura, video, and the computer were all innovations in their day, gradually becoming a natural part of artistic practice. So why not think of AI as just another tool?
Not every artist uses it in the same way, however. Some use it to experiment with compositions or explore variations before moving on to other media. For others, AI takes center stage, becoming the material they work with or the subject of their artistic explorations. Refik Anadol, for example, transforms vast amounts of data into moving landscapes that seem to breathe. Sougwen Chung draws alongside robotic arms trained on her own drawing style. In music, singer Maria Arnal has created Maria CHOIR, an interactive human-AI musical artwork. Designed to be experienced in person through singing, it allows participants to contribute to the creation of a new collective synthetic voice. A music video featuring Björk and Rosalía uses AI and deepfake technology to alter the artists’ faces and bodies to simulate an intense, choreographed fight. In these cases, technology is not merely a means of creating art; it becomes the very framework that shapes and defines the work itself.
Meanwhile, many exhibitions in recent years have explored what it means to be human in a postindustrial society, including Still Human at Espacio Solo in Madrid and the recent New Humans: Memories of the Future at the New Museum in New York.
Institutions have taken notice, too. In February 2024, Spain’s Ministry of Culture published a guide to best practices that excluded works created entirely and exclusively with generative AI from service contracts, national awards, and grants, while still allowing AI to be used as a supporting tool.
Behind these decisions lies a question that, as so often happens, ultimately becomes a legal one: Who is the author?
And that raises a host of other questions. If AI generates content, can we call it a work of art? Should it enjoy the same protection as a work created without AI? Who would have the right to exploit it commercially? And what content was used to train the AI in the first place? All these questions revolve around the same tension: creativity has always been seen as a uniquely human ability, but the quality of what AI can produce is now challenging that assumption.
As technology has advanced, things have become more complicated. Until recently, a computer program essentially did what its programmer had intended. To find out who was behind a particular result, it was enough to trace the work back to its source. Today’s systems are different. They learn from vast amounts of data, keep learning with each new use, and generate responses that even their creators cannot predict. The programmer is no longer in complete control.
To answer these questions, we first need to understand what intellectual property law actually protects—and what it doesn’t. A common misconception is that it protects ideas. It doesn’t. What it protects is the particular way in which an idea is expressed. Spain’s Intellectual Property Law defines an author as a natural person who creates a literary, artistic, or scientific work. And to qualify for protection, that work must be original.
But original doesn’t necessarily mean novel or valuable, even if it often is. According to the Court of Justice of the European Union, a work is original when it reflects its author’s personality through the free and creative choices made in producing it. So if originality is an expression of personality, it follows that only someone with a personality—in other words, a human being—can be an author.
Continental European legal tradition takes the view that a work reflects its creator’s own intellectual and aesthetic choices, which are inherently subjective. A machine, by contrast, has no perspective of its own from which to make such choices. It simply follows instructions. European law also protects not only economic rights but also moral rights, including the right to be recognized as the author, the right to preserve the integrity of a work, and the right to withdraw it from the market. These rights are inherent to the individual. Without a flesh-and-blood human being behind it, there can be no copyright-protected work. The legal conclusion, therefore, is that AI cannot be considered the author of the content it generates, as it is not human.
That brings us to the person writing the instructions, known as prompts, who can only be considered the author to the extent that they genuinely control the outcome. Anyone who has ever entered a prompt into an AI image generator knows that what appears on the screen rarely matches the image they had in mind. So if the result doesn’t match what someone envisioned, they haven’t truly controlled the outcome. And without that control, they cannot be said to have made their own creative choices or expressed their personality through the work. But when someone uses AI with a clear creative intent, providing input, guiding the process, and refining the output until they achieve what they had in mind, AI becomes just another tool, much like a paintbrush.
For now, the answer comes down to one simple idea: a work of art bears a human imprint. Perhaps another clue lies in the very concept of the prompt. Associated with an immediate response, the term has emerged to describe an act of will: the creative impulse that has always driven experimentation and, with it, progress in the arts. In this sense, it’s worth recalling the Viennese art historian Alois Riegl, who coined the term Kunstwollen (literally, “will to art”). In doing so, he established artistic intent as the defining element of any creative practice: without it, we can make all kinds of things, but they won’t be art.
NEXT IN Summit is the event promoted by ACCIONA Cultura that brings together international leaders in the cultural field to share experiences, discuss ideas and analyze the challenges that will shape the future of the cultural industry.